Attorneys often begin a case with the assumption that one expert witness will be enough to strengthen their argument. But as litigation unfolds, the reality is far more complex. Cases can quickly expand, requiring multiple experts across different specialties to provide the breadth and depth of testimony needed. At Homestead, we see this pattern firsthand. What starts as a request for one expert frequently evolves into the need for a multi-disciplinary team of expert witnesses. Navigating that evolution well can mean the difference between a strong case strategy and one with critical blind spots.
When One Expert Isn’t Enough
In a recent case Homestead supported, counsel initially requested a toxicology expert witness to analyze alcohol levels following an accident. At first glance, this seemed straightforward. But as we worked closely with the attorney and an initial round of experts, it became clear that standard toxicology wasn’t sufficient. The matter required a forensic toxicology expert witness to interpret post-mortem results accurately.
Through multiple rounds of sourcing and vetting, our team guided counsel toward the right sub-specialty expertise. Because of our involvement, the case strategy shifted from relying on a single perspective to incorporating specialized expertise that addressed the core issue.
The Complexity of Medical Specialties
Another active case handled by Homestead demonstrates how quickly expert needs can evolve. Attorneys approached us seeking a pain management expert witness for a dispute involving a procedure. On closer review, we identified that the case could also call for an interventional radiology expert, anesthesiology expert witness, or orthopedic expert witness, each with a different, yet potentially critical, perspective.
Complicating matters further, this case was in a rural state where finding a local expert was essential to manage costs and meet state requirements. Drawing on our extended referral network, we sourced an expert from out of state, who in turn helped us identify a qualified, in-state physician. The attorney ultimately retained a Tennessee-based expert who fit the exact profile needed.
Why Expert Needs Evolve
Because we’re directly involved in these cases, we see the drivers that often turn a single-specialty request into a multi-disciplinary strategy:
- Sub-specialty distinctions that determine credibility or admissibility.
- State-specific requirements for medical malpractice expert witnesses.
- Counterarguments introduced by opposing counsel that expand the scope of expertise needed.
- Strategic considerations such as cost management or juror perception.
In fact, two to three of our cases each month evolve this way. What begins with one expert expands into a multi-disciplinary team of expert witnesses.
Homestead’s Role in Building the Right Multi-Disciplinary Team of Expert Witnesses
Homestead is not a directory lookup service. We actively recruit and vet experts, often through referrals within our trusted network, to ensure attorneys have the precise qualifications needed. Our team frequently works in circumstances where sourcing can be uniquely challenging, and our relationships allow us to secure expert witnesses in specialized fields who might otherwise be difficult to reach.
Because of this direct involvement, we’re able to anticipate where cases might expand and guide attorneys toward the right mix of experts at the right time.
Perspective from Our Team
“The best outcomes happen when attorneys collaborate with their experts early and often. Case strategy isn’t just about having the right expert, it’s about having the right team at the right time.”
— Natalia Granados, Expert Witness Recruiter, Homestead
Conclusion
Expert witness needs frequently evolve beyond a single specialization. At Homestead, we see this pattern in multiple cases every month – what starts as a single request often expands into a multi-disciplinary team effort. Building the right team ensures every dimension of a matter is addressed.
We don’t just fill requests, we guide attorneys through this evolution. By combining strategic insight with a trusted sourcing process, we ensure the right experts are identified, vetted, and aligned to strengthen case outcomes.
If you’re building your next case strategy, contact Homestead to explore how we can help anticipate and meet your evolving expert witness needs.
